Midland County Bundles Innovative Steel Bridge System and Saves Big
How do you know it’s spring in Michigan? Seeing the road change from white to brown; feeling the pavement change from smooth to bumpy and back again; witnessing a family of deer soaking up the sun near a drainage ditch full of snow and water…..and your peaceful drive coming to a stop for a bridge closed to traffic.
This is the experience you’ll have driving through Midland County, Michigan in the early spring months. Located nearest to Saginaw, Midland is a typical rural county in the United States. And like many of them, Midland’s rural county government agency is responsible for an increasing inventory of deteriorated bridges with a decreasing supply of funding.
Faced with the growing dilemma of replacing bridges with reduced funding, some counties have found increased efficiencies through manufacturing and constructing multiple bridges in one contract, a process known as “bundling.” Bridge bundling saves time and costs by eliminating the need for multiple contracts. The process involves pre-ordering multiple bridges and making these prefabricated bridge superstructures available for later installation by the county’s own labor force.
The Midland County Road Commission and its structural consultant, OHM Advisors, recognized the benefits of bundling when searching for an economical method to replace two structurally deficient bridges—the Orr Road Bridge over Weaks Drain and the Grey Road Bridge over Bullock Creek. To get the “most bang for the buck,” the Midland County Road Commission combined multiple innovative cost-cutting measures:
- Bundling the two bridges into a single package,
- Pre-ordering the bridge superstructures to be manufactured at the same time,
- Incorporating Geosynthetic Reinforced Soil (GRS) abutments, and
- Selecting the Con-Struct™ Prefabricated Bridge System (now known as the Valmont® Structures Con-Struct™ Prefabricated Bridge System), a press-brake-formed steel tub girder system that consists of a precast concrete deck on galvanized steel tub girders. This Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC) product can be installed quickly and has a very long service life.
Once the bridge bunding process was set in place, the project was ready to move ahead.
Project Timeline
- July 2018 – OHM Advisors releases a single project for bid. The bid requires materials for both bridges to be delivered by spring 2019.
- August 2018 – Valmont® Structures Con-Struct™ Prefabricated Bridge System is awarded the project and begins the design and shop drawing process.
- September 2018 – The design and drawings are reviewed and approved by OHM Advisors.
- September 2018 – Valmont Structures begins fabrication of the steel press-brake-formed tub girders (PBFTGs).
- December 2018 – The fabrication and galvanization of all 12 PBFTGs are completed.
- January 2019 – The girders are shipped to ADL Systems, a precast concrete producer.
- April 2018/2019 – The precast concrete deck is manufactured. ADL completes the process and stockpiles the 12 bridge tub girder units until Midland County Road Commission is ready to install them.
- May 2019 – An extremely wet spring and summer prevents the use of GRS Abutments for the Orr Road Bridge. If using a contractor and a traditional method of bridge construction, this situation could have created extra costs for the owner with the need for dewatering to deal with high stream water levels; or, due to an extended construction schedule, the need to use heating and housing for pouring concrete in the cold winter months.
- August 2019 – The Midland County Road Commission takes delivery of 6 Valmont Con-Struct™ prefabricated bridge units for installation atop the county-installed GRS abutments for the Orr Road Bridge.
Installation of the Orr Road Bridge was completed by the end of August 2019. The bridge deck joints were then filled with a durable, high-strength polymer concrete product known as Transpo T-17. After Midland County Road Commission installed the bridge rail, the Orr Road Bridge opened to traffic in October 2019.
For the next project, the Grey Road Bridge, the additional 6 Valmont Con-Struct™ prefabricated bridge units were then delivered to the Midland County Road Commission. They are awaiting installation in 2020, whenever spring in Michigan finally decides to show up and the county’s labor force has completed its snow plowing duties.
The innovative bridge bundling concept is capturing the attention of county transportation officials nationwide. As the U.S. bridge inventory continues to age, faster and more efficient bridge replacement techniques and cost-saving measures like bridge bundling will become more widespread. For additional information on these projects, visit Valmont Structures.
What are Press Brake Tub Girders?
Press-brake-formed tub girder (PBTG) is a new technology for short span bridge applications. It consists of modular galvanized shallow trapezoidal boxes fabricated from cold-bent structural steel plate (watch fabrication video). A concrete deck is recommended to be precast on the girder and the modular unit can be shipped by truck to the bridge site.
The system utilizes standard plate widths (based on availability) and is optimized to achieve maximum structural capacity, with most of the steel in the bottom flange and increased torsional stiffness. It is a closed system, since the girder is closed at the bottom. It is versatile for multiple-deck options.
The system utilizes Accelerated Bridge Construction practices, since it:
- Can be installed in one or two days
- Is modular, allowing the use of a precast deck
- Is cost-effective―as much as 1/3 less than a standard concrete girder structure
- Is simple to fabricate, requiring very little welding.
The Short Span Steel Bridge Alliance has developed standardized plans using standard plate sizes (60”, 72” 84”, 96”, 108”, 120”). The designs were developed to achieve maximum structural capacity and are available to use in the free-to-use, web-based design tool eSPAN140.
The press-brake-formed tub girder system is open source.
Whiteside County (IL) Uses FHWA Funds for Accelerated Steel Bridge Project
Russ Renner, a Whiteside County Engineer, saved up to 12 weeks of lane closures by installing a steel bridge for the crossing.
SSSBA and WV LTAP Team Up for Steel Bridge Workshop
The SSSBA and WVDOH collaborated on a bridge workshop to discuss the design of steel bridges with cost-effective, time-saving options for states and counties.
On-Demand Steel Bridge Video Series: Learning By Example
A distinguished panel of 8 industry experts to present case studies that offer innovative and cost-effective examples of steel bridge replacement projects.
“Save a Bundle with Tub Girders” – Modern Steel Construction
The Michigan DOT shaved a year off its three year schedule by using bundled press-brake-formed tub girders for a 19 bridge replacement project.
Bridge Workshops: Changing Minds One Workshop at a Time
The SSSBA and Barron County, WI collaborated on a bridge workshop to discuss the replacement of aging bridges with cost-effective, time-saving steel options for state and county bridges.
SSSBA and Barron County Team Up for Steel Bridge Workshop
The SSSBA and Barron County, WI collaborated on a bridge workshop to discuss the replacement of aging bridges with cost-effective, time-saving steel options for state and county bridges.